Pay and payroll
How do I calculate technician bonuses and commissions from completed jobs?
Write each pay rule down as a formula on job data (for example 5% of the invoice subtotal less materials on jobs the tech sold, or 10% of completed revenue split by hours for a crew), and calculate it only from jobs that are completed, invoiced and past any callback window. Store the result per person per pay period as a line the technician can see, then send the total to payroll as a separate bonus or commission pay type. In the US, a bonus paid by a known formula is nondiscretionary, so it also raises the overtime rate for any week it was earned.
- Every rule is a formula on fields the job already has: sold by, worked by, hours, revenue, cost, zone, callback.
- Pay only on jobs that are completed and invoiced, and take back jobs reworked inside a set callback window.
- Crew bonuses need a split rule: equal, by hours worked, or a lead and helper percentage.
- Technicians should see their own breakdown by job, not just a total on the paycheck.
- US: a formula bonus goes into the regular rate for overtime (DOL Fact Sheet #56C).
This page is about working out the numbers from job data. It is not payroll: tax withholding, pay stubs and filings stay in your payroll provider, and the rules themselves should be checked with your accountant or employment adviser.
Facts checked as of November 2026. Sources at the end of the page.
Step by step
How job-based bonus and commission pay works, step by step
Bonus and commission pay goes wrong when the rule lives in someone's head or in a sheet formula nobody else can read. Start by writing the rule, then make sure each job carries the fields the rule needs.
1. Write each rule as a formula
Name the basis (invoice subtotal, gross profit, stops completed, hours under budget), the rate or tier, who earns it (sold by, worked by, the whole crew) and when it is earned (job completed, invoice paid, end of pay period). One rule per line, e.g. Sales commission = 5% x (invoice subtotal less materials) on jobs where you are Sold by.
2. Put the inputs on the job
Each job needs: Sold by, Worked by (one or more people), clocked hours per person, invoice subtotal, material and equipment cost, service type, zone or route, completion date and a callback flag. If a rule uses a field the job does not capture, the office ends up typing it in later.
3. Decide what makes a job eligible
Typical gates: status Completed, invoice raised (or paid, if you pay on collection), photos and checklist complete, and no callback within e.g. 7 or 14 days. A job that fails a gate stays in a Pending bonus state rather than being dropped silently.
4. Apply the split
When two or more people worked a job, the rule says how credit divides: equal shares, by hours each person clocked on the job, or a fixed split such as 60/40 for lead and helper. The split is stored on the job so it can be checked later.
5. Add modifiers and attendance rules
Zone or route premiums (e.g. $5 per stop in an outer zone), tiers (a higher rate once revenue passes a threshold) and attendance bonuses that are lost for late clock ins. Treat a lost bonus as a bonus not earned, not a deduction from wages.
6. Close the period and publish statements
At the end of the pay period, lock the period, total each person's lines and publish a statement that lists every job, its basis, the rate, the split and the amount. Technicians check their own statement before payroll runs.
7. Send totals to payroll as their own pay types
Export hours, bonus and commission as separate amounts per employee so payroll treats them as separate earnings. In QuickBooks payroll, commission is added under the employee's Job and pay tab as an additional pay type, and can be paid on a scheduled run or as a Commission only payroll.
8. Recalculate overtime where required
For non-exempt US employees, add each nondiscretionary bonus to the week it was earned before working out the overtime rate. A bonus that covers several weeks is spread back over those weeks.
Failure modes
Why it goes wrong
The spreadsheet hits its limits
A lawn care company with 55 to 60 staff at peak season ran crew time clock, pay rates, zone bonuses and late penalties in Google Sheets with Apps Script, and told us the sheet runs out of function calls at scale. Google's published quotas cap a custom function at 30 seconds per execution and a script at 6 minutes per execution, and limit time-driven triggers to 90 minutes a day on a consumer account.
Completed work is typed in twice
The same company keyed what each crew actually completed from its scheduling tool into the bonus sheet by hand. Every bonus dispute then turns into a question of which copy is right.
Clock ins happen from the road
Crews that clock in before they reach the truck or the first site inflate the hours that bonuses are split by. The buyer wanted clock in limited to a geofence, and a UK cleaning contractor asked for GPS clock in and out that feeds payroll hours, plus breaks and an overtime report.
Technicians cannot see how their number was made
The lawn care buyer wanted an employee login with a bonus view and a leaderboard. When a technician only sees a total on the paycheck, every short week becomes a conversation with the office.
Performance pay sits in a tool that is too big
A plumbing and HVAC company of 3 or 4 people, under 300 jobs a month, was leaving a large platform because it was too much software for its size, and asked whether a simpler tool would still have a time clock, performance pay and commission tracking.
Callbacks are paid twice
If the bonus is paid when the job closes and the callback happens two weeks later, the company pays for the work once in bonus and again in rework hours. The rule needs a callback window and a clawback or hold.
Options
Ways to do it
Six real approaches. Ask the same three questions of each: does it read the rule's inputs straight from the job, can it express your splits and modifiers, and can a technician see their own breakdown.
| Approach | How the calculation works | Where it falls short |
|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheet with formulas or Apps Script | Completed jobs are pasted or imported into a sheet, and formulas or scripts apply rates, zones and splits. Any rule can be written. | Job data is re-keyed, nobody but the author can safely change the formulas, and Apps Script quotas apply: 30 seconds per custom function, 6 minutes per script run. |
| Performance pay (ServiceTitan) | ServiceTitan's help center says performance pay covers sales commissions and bonus pay for invoice items on completed jobs. Commission goes to the tech with Sold by credit, item bonuses use item price x split x commission rate from the pricebook, and range bonuses pay a tiered percentage of split-adjusted revenue per pay period. | Settings span the technician's payroll tab, each pricebook item and, on newer accounts, Configurable Payroll pay profiles that take precedence. Several options stack, so the rules need care to avoid paying twice. |
| Commissions on the job (Housecall Pro) | Commissions are switched on under Settings, Jobs, Costs and Materials, Manage Pay. People on the job become Worked by on each line item, sellers are added by hand, and commission is revenue based or gross profit based (revenue less material and labor cost), with manual splits. | Its help center says commissions apply to jobs only, not estimates, and the Commissions card is not available in the mobile app. Manual Split is the only method for gross profit commissions. |
| Budget-based crew bonus (Aspire with Protiv) | For landscaping. Protiv links Aspire work tickets and their labor budgets to team incentives, imports time on each ticket, and gives workers statements showing which jobs came in under budget and earned a bonus. | A second product on top of the FSM. Rework time comes out of the team's bonus, which is a choice to agree with crews in writing first. |
| Hourly or commission, whichever is higher (LawnPro); labor cost only (Jobber) | LawnPro calculates hourly and commission earnings for each employee and pays the higher, with crew splits of full to each, equal, or by time worked. Jobber's job costing article calculates labor cost from timesheets and each user's hourly cost. | LawnPro is built for lawn care. The Jobber job costing article does not mention commissions or bonuses, so a bonus rule would be worked out outside it. |
| A configurable field service platform (Fieldproxy) | Your own pay rules are set up as calculations on job fields (sold by, worked by, clocked hours, revenue, cost, zone, callback), with per-period statements technicians see in their app and an export to payroll. | The rules are built for your business during setup, not chosen from a fixed menu. Payroll itself stays with your payroll provider. |
Vendor facts are from each vendor's own help or product pages, read in November 2026. Features change, so check the linked page.
Worked example
A worked example: one crew, one week
Say a lawn care company pays crew members $20 an hour plus a production bonus. The written rule: the crew bonus pool is 10% of revenue on stops completed that week, less any stop reworked within 7 days, plus $5 for each stop in Zone C. The pool is split by hours each person clocked. Each person also earns a $25 attendance bonus for a week with no late clock ins.
| Line | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Stops completed | 110 stops | $5,500 revenue |
| Callbacks inside 7 days | 2 stops removed | less $100 |
| Eligible revenue | $5,500 less $100 | $5,400 |
| Production pool | 10% x $5,400 | $540 |
| Zone C premium | 20 stops x $5 | $100 |
| Crew pool | $540 + $100 | $640 |
| Crew lead share | $640 x 44 / 84 hours | $335.24 |
| Crew member share | $640 x 40 / 84 hours | $304.76 |
A worked example with made-up figures. $335.24 + $304.76 = $640.
The lead had no late clock ins and earns the $25 attendance bonus. The member was late twice and does not. So the lead's bonuses are $335.24 + $25 = $360.24, and the member's is $304.76.
Now overtime. The lead worked 44 hours. Straight time pay is 44 x $20 = $880. Following the method in DOL Fact Sheet #56C, the regular rate is ($880 + $360.24) / 44 = $28.19. The overtime premium is half that rate for the 4 overtime hours: 0.5 x $28.19 x 4 = $56.37. Total pay for the week is $880 + $360.24 + $56.37 = $1,296.61.
If the bonus were left out of the regular rate, the overtime premium would be 0.5 x $20 x 4 = $40, which underpays the lead by $16.37 for that one week. The member worked 40 hours, so there is no overtime: $800 + $304.76 = $1,104.76.
Each person's statement lists the 110 stops, the two callbacks that were removed, the 20 Zone C stops and the hours used for the split, so the number can be checked before payroll runs.
Before you buy
What to check before you choose a tool
Good signs
- Bonus and commission lines are calculated from job fields, not typed in after the fact.
- One job can credit a seller and several workers, each with their own share.
- Splits can be equal, by clocked hours, or a fixed lead and helper percentage.
- Rules can use your own modifiers: zones, service types, tiers, callbacks, attendance.
- Clock in can be limited to a geofence around the site or yard.
- Technicians see a statement by job in their own app or login.
- A pay period can be locked, and late changes show as adjustments, not silent edits.
- Hours, bonus and commission export to payroll as separate amounts per employee.
Red flags
- Commission is only a percentage of the invoice, with no way to take off materials or callbacks.
- Crew bonuses must be split by hand outside the tool.
- The rules are a fixed menu and your zone or attendance rule does not fit.
- Technicians cannot see their own numbers, or the feature is web only.
- A paid-out job can be edited after the period closes without a trace.
- The vendor treats the bonus total as payroll, with no overtime handling or export.
In Fieldproxy
Setting it up in Fieldproxy
Fieldproxy is set up around your own process, so pay rules are fields, statuses and calculations configured for your account. Values marked e.g. are examples to replace with your own.
Pay fields on the job
Each job carries Sold by, Worked by, the clocked hours of each person from the technician app, the invoice subtotal, material cost, service type, zone and a callback flag. Your rate table holds each person's base rate, commission rate and e.g. zone premiums.
GPS clock in on the technician app
Crews clock in and out on the Android or iOS app with GPS check-in, so the hours used for splits and overtime come from the field, not from memory. See GPS timesheet verification for how clock ins are checked against the site.
Your rules as calculations
Each rule is written once, e.g. 10% of eligible revenue split by hours, 5% of subtotal less materials to the seller, $25 attendance bonus. A job only produces a bonus line when it reaches e.g. Completed and invoiced and passes the callback window.
Statements technicians can see
Each person sees their own lines by job and their running total for the period in the app, with no access to anyone else's. A leaderboard or crew view can sit on a dashboard for managers.
Watcher agent on the exceptions
The Watcher agent flags jobs with no Worked by, clock ins far from the site, callbacks against a job already paid, and periods that are about to close with jobs still pending.
Scheduler agent and Command Center at period end
The Scheduler agent emails the pay period summary to the office on e.g. Monday morning. In Command Center you can ask in plain English why one technician's bonus dropped this week, and it answers from the job lines.
Export to payroll
A pay period report gives hours, bonus and commission per employee as separate amounts for your payroll provider, while invoices sync with QuickBooks or Xero. Fieldproxy is one price per company with unlimited users, so every crew member can have a login to see their statement.
By country
Rules that change the calculation
Pay rules are employment law, not just software settings. Three that change what the calculation has to do:
United States: formula bonuses go into overtime
The Department of Labor lists bonuses based on a predetermined formula, such as individual or group production bonuses, quality bonuses, attendance bonuses and safety bonuses, as nondiscretionary, because employees know about and expect them. They are included in the regular rate used for overtime. A truly discretionary, on-the-spot bonus can be excluded.
California: commission plans must be in writing
Labor Code section 2751 says that when pay involves commissions for work in California, the contract must be in writing and set out how commissions are computed and paid. The employer gives each employee a signed copy and gets a signed receipt. Short-term productivity bonuses and temporary incentives that only increase pay are excluded from that definition.
United Kingdom: commission counts in holiday pay
GOV.UK says normal pay for holiday includes commission and regular overtime, and does not usually include bonus payments. Where pay varies, holiday pay uses the average over the last 52 weeks in which the worker was paid. So the system must keep each person's commission history, not only this period's total.
How switching works
How switching to Fieldproxy works
We move your data over and set the system up to the way you already work. Fieldproxy replaces the old tool; it does not run alongside it.
Bring the sheet and two pay statements
Show us the bonus sheet or scripts you run today and two real statements, one simple and one disputed. We read the rules out of them with you.We write the rules down and build them
Each rule becomes a calculation on job fields, with your splits, zones, tiers, callback window and attendance rules, set up before you commit.Run one past pay period side by side
We load a past period's jobs and hours and compare the result with what you actually paid, line by line, until the numbers match or the differences are explained.Crews get their statements
Technicians clock in on the app and see their own lines as jobs complete. The office closes the period and exports to payroll.
FAQ
Questions people ask
- Can field service software replace a Google Sheets and Apps Script bonus system?
- Yes, if it can read the inputs straight from completed jobs and express your rules, including splits, zones and attendance. Run one past pay period through both and compare before switching.
- Can technicians see their bonus and pay breakdown on their phone?
- They should. A statement per pay period, listing each job, the basis, the rate and the share, cuts most disputes. Check that the vendor shows it in the mobile app and not only on the web.
- Should commission be on revenue or on gross profit?
- Revenue is simpler and easy to check. Gross profit (revenue less materials and sometimes labor) stops techs being paid for low-margin work. Many companies pay on revenue less materials as a middle ground.
- How should a crew bonus be split?
- The common options are equal shares, shares by hours each person clocked on the job, or a fixed lead and helper percentage. Hours-based splits are fairest when crews change during the week, but they depend on accurate clock ins.
- Do bonuses affect overtime pay?
- In the US, yes for most production, quality, attendance and safety bonuses paid under a known rule. They go into the regular rate for the week they were earned, which raises the overtime premium. Ask your payroll provider how they handle it.
- Can clock in be blocked until the crew reaches the site or yard?
- Many tools record the GPS position at clock in. Check whether the tool can restrict clock in to a geofence or only flag clock ins outside it, and which of those you want.
- Can I import completed jobs from my current scheduling tool and calculate bonuses on import?
- It works as a bridge, but it keeps the double entry. The cleaner fix is to run jobs and clock ins in the same system that calculates pay, so the inputs are never retyped.
- Does a bonus system replace payroll?
- No. It works out the amounts. Withholding, pay stubs and filings stay with your payroll provider, which receives hours, bonus and commission as separate pay types.
Sources
Competitor details on this page come from the vendors' own pages and documentation, checked as of November 2026. Plans and prices change, so check the vendor's current page before you decide.
- ServiceTitan Help: Performance pay overview: https://help.servicetitan.com/docs/performance-pay-overview
- Housecall Pro Help Center: Using commission on the job: https://help.housecallpro.com/en/articles/6649542-using-commission-on-the-job
- Housecall Pro Help Center: Gross profit vs revenue commissions: https://help.housecallpro.com/en/articles/12657750-what-s-the-difference-between-gross-profit-and-revenue-commissions
- Aspire Marketplace: Protiv: https://marketplace.youraspire.com/partners/protiv
- LawnPro: Pay for performance: https://lawnprosoftware.com/features/pay-for-performance
- Jobber Help Center: Job costing: https://help.getjobber.com/es/articles/job-costing/
- Google Apps Script: Quotas for Google services: https://developers.google.com/apps-script/guides/services/quotas
- QuickBooks: Pay employees commission: https://quickbooks.intuit.com/learn-support/en-us/help-article/pay-commissions/pay-employees-commission/L4Sz47WWY_US_en_US
- US Department of Labor: Fact Sheet #56C, Bonuses under the FLSA: https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/56c-bonuses
- California Labor Code section 2751: https://california.public.law/codes/labor_code_section_2751
- GOV.UK: Holiday pay: https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights/holiday-pay
Related
Keep reading
- Verify technician timesheets with GPS
- Hide prices from technicians
- Technician expenses and receipts on jobs
- When your process doesn't fit a template
- What is the best field service software for a 5-10 person HVAC team?
- Cheaper ServiceTitan alternatives for small plumbing and HVAC companies, without payment processor lock-in